I’ve been a fan of Brett Favre since his start with the Green Bay Packers (and I’ve been a fan of the Green Bay Packers since birth). OK, maybe I wasn’t fully on board the first year or two when his interceptions seemed to outnumber his completions, but we can all agree he came around quite nicely. What Brett has accomplished, and what he’s helped the Packers accomplish, will live on forever. Considering how many of us live vicariously through our hero’s, this makes his legend not only his, but ours. Who doesn’t love to reminisce about the time they witnessed Brett pull off some unbelievable feat? It’s what makes sports worth watching, and it helps to bring us all together as we share our memories.
In the past couple years, as talk of Brett retiring has peppered sports news, I’ve held out the hope that Brett won’t hang ‘em up yet. With Favre in there, it seems their is always a chance to win. Besides that, their are so many records he could still break, and 30 years from now, I want to brag that I was there when they were broken. Then came the 2005 season, and we got to see a Brett Favre, and a Packer team that we hadn’t seen in over 10 years. In the last game, they set it up so Brett could give what might be his farewell wave as he left the field. It’s OK though, I told myself, Brett will return, we’ll get our guys healthy, pick up a few players to plug the holes, and we can still make another run.
Well, someone didn’t agree with my assessment, and now I have to keep searching my memory for our new coaches name (hmm, oh yea, McCarthy). This is going to make things a bit tougher, but hey, still doable. We’ve got cash in the bank, pick up the right free agents, and we can make a run, we have to take advantage of the fact that we’ve got a pro-bowl caliber quarterback. Meanwhile, Favre isn’t telling us that he’s coming back. Deadlines come, deadlines go, still no decision. Free agency comes, free agency goes, still no decision (and no notable additions to the team, only losses). The team is waiting on Favre before it decides what to do, and Favre is waiting on the team before he makes a decision. This is not good.
I still had my hopes, that maybe, somehow, things could work out. That was until recently, when Brett said something he hadn’t said before. “If I do play this year, it will be my last. There’s no doubt about that.” Now, based on the actions, or more accurately inaction of our general manager, it’s becoming obvious that we are a team that is rebuilding. Everything suggests that we are looking for young, inexperienced talent that can be molded into a great team… some day. That’s not going to happen this year, this year we’ll be lucky to win half of our games. So, if we don’t stand a chance of going to the Super Bowl, then why would Brett come back? At this point any reason he chooses to come back would be the wrong reason.
Brett needs to retire so the Green Bay Packers can turn the page. Staying around for one more year not only will further tarnish his legend with memories of dismal performances due to lack of a supporting cast, but will delay the rebuilding process for another year as well. Both are important points to consider. The good of the team is most important, the Packers are bigger than Brett Favre, and Brett needs to realize what is best for the team, and take a bow. Brett’s legend is important as well though, and though his play wasn’t very impressive last season, in time most will forget that. What may not be forgotten though is the process we are going through now, Brett’s delayed decision. With every day that passes, Brett looks worse in the eyes of the media, in the eyes of the players, and in the eyes of his fans. Had he retired earlier, we wouldn’t have heard him say “If I don’t tell them by Saturday, what will they do, cut me?”. If he’d made his decision we probably wouldn’t be hearing “He’s a selfish guy…” from one of his former best friend’s, Mark Chmura. The more time that passes, the more ugliness we’re going to witness.
With a little time the ugliness that’s started developing will be forgotten, but I fear a monster is lurking just around the corner, and that once it rears it’s ugly head, we may never think of Brett Favre in the same way again. Brett said himself “If we can’t compete at a high level, I can walk away and my legacy will speak for itself.” Well, Brett, for the sake of the Packers, for the sake of Packer fans and Brett Favre fans, and for the sake of your legacy, it’s time to walk away…